Candle Wick Test Sheet: compare 3–4 wick sizes side by side
Pour the same candle three or four times, change only the wick, and burn them together. This test matrix puts wicks A, B, C and D in columns on one sheet, burn after burn, so the right size stands out: full melt pool, the right depth, a steady flame, no mushrooming, no soot. Then it works out the fragrance to weigh out and what each candle costs you to make.
How to run a side-by-side wick test: seven steps, from choosing the sizes to the burn-down, and how to measure pool width, pool depth, flame height, mushrooming, soot, hang-up and hot throw.
Reading the results: what a tunnel, a deep pool, a tall flame or a mushroomed wick usually means, and which size to test next.
Test setup sheet: vessel, wax, fragrance, load, pour and cure details, the four wicks under test, and a fragrance load worksheet.
Four burn session sheets: wicks A to D side by side, with pool width at each hour, full pool reached, depth, flame, mushroom and soot scores, hang-up and throw.
Wick verdict sheet: every burn summed up on one page, and the checks the winning wick must pass.
Cost per candle worksheet: wax, fragrance, wick, vessel, lid, label and packing, with a price and margin check.
A burn log that does the sums
Burn log: one row per wick per burn; the pool percentage works itself out and is highlighted when the pool reaches the glass.
Wick summary: burns logged, full pools and the average depth, flame, mushroom, soot and throw for each wick, pulled from the log.
Fragrance load calculator: wax weight and load in, fragrance weight, total pour and fill per candle out.
Cost per candle: one row per recipe, with cost, profit and margin at your selling price.
A fill-in wick test record
Type in one test (setup, wicks, every burn, your verdict and the cost per candle) and print a clean record for your files, as often as you like. Add your logo if you want.
A look at the burn session sheet
Check
Wick A
Wick B
Wick C
Wick D
Series and size
ECO 6
ECO 8
ECO 10
ECO 12
Pool width at 3 h (in)
2.2
2.7
3.0
3.0
Pool depth (in)
0.2
0.3
0.45
0.7
Flame height (in)
0.5
0.7
0.9
1.4
Mushrooming (0–3)
0
0
1
2
Soot (0–3)
0
0
0
1
Hot throw (1–5)
2
3
4
4
An example burn in a 3-inch vessel: A is too small (tunnelling), D too large (deep pool, tall flame, soot), C is the one to keep testing. The sheets come blank, with this example in the burn log so you can see how it works.
Questions
Does it tell me which wick to buy?
No. It helps you test the sizes you already have and pick the best from what you see. Start from your wick supplier's chart for your vessel and wax, and test the sizes either side of it.
Does it work with soy, coconut, paraffin or blends?
Yes. The sheets record what the wax does, whatever it is. Soy and other vegetable waxes usually need a larger wick than paraffin, so expect to test a little higher.
Which wick series does it cover?
Any: you write in the series and size. ECO in the example is only an example.
How is the fragrance load worked out?
By the weight of the wax: fragrance weight = wax weight × load % ÷ 100. 16 oz of wax at 8% takes 1.28 oz of fragrance. If your supplier states the load as a share of the total pour, the setup sheet points that out so you can adjust.
Ounces or grams?
Either for the load, as long as you use one unit throughout. The cost per candle sheet asks for wax per candle in ounces and prices per ounce.
How many burns should I run?
At least three before you choose, then burn the best one or two down to the last 1/2 inch. There are four burn sheets, and you can print more.
Is it for wide or multi-wick vessels?
It works for any vessel you test with one wick per candle. For two-wick candles, write both wicks in a column.